Anyone can make a bad movie. That is one of the great filmmaking truths, and it ought to be embroidered on a pillow somewhere.
The difficult part is not getting a movie made. The difficult part is getting it made right. A funny premise, a recognizable franchise, a giant budget, or a famous actor will not save a movie if the basic ingredients are wrong. And in comedy, there are about a million ways to lose it.
That is why I have always cared less about playing the Hollywood game and more about protecting the idea. Whether it is a spoof, a farce, a black-and-white film noir comedy, or an international spy thriller, the job is the same: write something original, make it funny, give the audience somebody to care about, and do not ruin it by trying too hard.
If You Want To Make A Great Movie You Have To Get These Two Things Right
If the casting is wrong, you can lose the movie. If the director is wrong, you can lose the movie. Those are the two big things.
A script can be terrific, but if it lands with a director who does not understand the particular form, especially spoof, there is no point. Spoof comedy is deceptively difficult because it has to operate as two things at once. It has to be a real movie with real stakes, but it also has to be funny. If the director treats it like a sketch show, it falls apart. If the actors wink at the jokes, it falls apart. If the cast does not fit, it falls apart.
With Airplane!, the original question was whether three first-time directors could direct a feature, particularly a comedy made without conventional comedians. Paramount even had the right to fire us after two weeks. Then the first day of dailies came in, including Leslie Nielsen delivering the famous line about being serious and not calling him Shirley, and suddenly everybody understood the tone.
The actors were not trying to be funny. Leslie Nielsen was not doing a comedy performance in the usual sense. He was doing what he had done in dozens of dramas: playing the scene truthfully, seriously, and with conviction. That was the whole trick.
Protect the vision, but do not worship every detail
Early in a career, people often say you have to say yes to every opportunity. I do not think that is necessarily true. We said no when people wanted to buy the Airplane! script without us directing it. We said no when the studio wanted someone else behind the camera. That was worth protecting.
But protecting a vision does not mean refusing every compromise. We wanted the plane in Airplane! to be a prop plane because the original source, the 1957 thriller Zero Hour!, had a prop plane. Michael Eisner said the movie had to use a jet. He was firm about it. We gave in, and he was right.
The lesson is not “never compromise.” The lesson is to know the difference between a detail and the movie’s DNA. A jet was not the DNA. Directing the movie ourselves was.
The studio system has changed, and it is not especially interested in the kind of mid-budget comedy I want to make. That does not mean original movies are dead. It means independent financing matters more. Movies such as Sean Baker’s Anora show that there is always room for a low-budget original film that is written well, directed well, and built around a character with a real arc.
There are still large studio movies that work, too. Top Gun: Maverick was an expensive Hollywood film that was genuinely great. The problem is not that all studios make bad movies. The problem is that franchises, copies, remakes, and familiar properties are safer on paper than a fresh idea. Paper has no sense of humor.
Director David Zucker Reacts To Scary Movie Controversy
The story of Scary Movie 3 is not a story about stealing a franchise from the Wayans brothers. It is a story about a business deal that was not made and a different creative team being brought in afterward.
Bob Weinstein, who ran Dimension at the time, explained that they could not reach an agreement with the Wayans. In his view, they wanted more than he wanted to pay. That is negotiation. People can make their own choices, leave, make movies elsewhere, and do whatever they want. It is a free country.
Then I got the call to direct Scary Movie 3. I asked for the script, and the answer was essentially that there was no usable script. So I brought in Craig Mazin and Pat Proft, and we built one. I consider Scary Movie 3 one of my three best movies, along with Airplane! and The Naked Gun. It worked because the material, cast, pace, and tone all came together.
That does not mean it was trying to do what the Wayans did. Their Scary Movie films were hard R, edgy, and built around their own comic sensibility. They are the best at what they do. Their approach is different from mine, and it should be different. You cannot do the Wayans, and I would never try.
When I took on Scary Movie 3, I made one thing clear: I could do me. That meant PG-13. A PG-13 rating can broaden the audience, bringing in younger people and people who may not enjoy a hard-R comedy. But rating alone does not decide quality or success. The first Scary Movie was R-rated and did very well. These are apples and oranges.
I sincerely hope Scary Movie 6 does well. A successful spoof helps spoof comedy. A successful theatrical comedy helps theatrical comedy. I love going to the movies and laughing. Why would I root against that?
Controversy may be useful marketing for some people, but it is not my thing. I do not like artificial conflict. I want to write and direct movies. I want the work to be good. That is enough trouble already.
The Big Difference Between Fresh Ideas And Stolen Ones
All artists borrow. The ethical issue is not whether you were influenced by something. Everybody is influenced by something. The issue is whether you are transforming an idea into something fresh, or merely repeating another person’s work because you do not have a better idea.
Airplane! is a very clear example. It was based on Zero Hour!, and we did not hide that. We took the plot, the story mechanics, and even many of the situations. When John Landis read our script, he gave us the useful warning that it was not parody if we did not own the material. It was plagiarism. So we bought the rights.
That was the right thing to do creatively and legally. Then we used that serious disaster-movie structure as the framework for a totally different comic experience. The plot was recognizable, but the joke construction, visual comedy, rhythm, and performance style were ours.
Copying a character is not reinventing a franchise
If I had simply replaced Leslie Nielsen with another older actor playing Frank Drebin, surrounded him with the same characters, and repeated the old formula, that would be copying. It would be a bad copy, because Leslie Nielsen cannot be replaced. Have I made that clear?
The fresh version of that idea was to reboot the concept into an international spy franchise, closer to Mission: Impossible, Bourne, and James Bond. New cast, younger characters, new circumstances, same comic sensibility. That is not trying to replace Leslie. That is taking a familiar title and making a different movie.
That project became Counter Intelligence. Likewise, The Star of Malta is conceived as a real black-and-white film noir comedy, made as though it had come from the early 1950s. October Fest, written for Amazon Germany, is a straight-ahead farce rather than a spoof. Those are original ideas, even though the sense of humor remains recognizably mine.
I never wanted to make endless sequels. One Airplane!, two Naked Gun movies, two Scary Movie films, that was enough. Eventually, a premise gets tired out. It is more fun and easier to make something new than to imitate something old.
Experimentation includes failure
Originality is not a magical flash of genius followed by effortless perfection. Every sketch, scene, and cut is an experiment. You write it, shoot it, put it together, and discover whether it works.
We routinely shot more movie than we could use. A 90-minute comedy might lose 15 or 20 minutes in the editing process. Airplane! lost about half an hour. The first preview of Airplane! was terrible. The first previews of The Naked Gun and Scary Movie 3 were terrible, too. You get through it, keep cutting, and solve the problems.
Failure is part of the journey. If the joke does not get a laugh, it is not a joke anymore. It is furniture. Take it out.
That is why fearlessness matters more than cruelty. Funny people are not necessarily cruel, but the best ones are often willing to go a little further, risk bad taste, and risk failure. Jim Abrahams had that fearlessness. He brought real bite to Airplane!, Top Secret!, and parts of The Naked Gun.
A Few Comedy Lessons From A Comedy Filmmaking Master
The biggest misconception about spoof is that it is simply a collection of jokes. It is not. A good spoof needs real filmmaking underneath it. Structure, character, suspense, and timing are not optional just because somebody is about to walk into a wall.
Play the comedy seriously
In our kind of spoof, the writer is the comedian. The actors are the straight men and women. The jokes come from behind the camera, from the script, editing, staging, and visual contradiction.
Everybody in Airplane! took themselves seriously. Julie Hagerty, Robert Hays, Robert Stack, Peter Graves, Lloyd Bridges, and Leslie Nielsen all committed to the reality of the scene. There were no characters announcing that they were funny.
Steve Stucker was the exception, and he was there because he was hysterically funny in a very specific way. His flamboyant air traffic controller worked because he was a perfect foil against a world of dead-serious dramatic performers.
When Priscilla Presley was nervous about whether she could be funny, the direction was simple: do not try to be funny. Let the line do the work. If the line is funny, say it. Do not decorate it. Do not wink at it. Do not gild the lily.
That is why “comedic timing” in this kind of spoof is often really dramatic timing. Leslie did not suddenly become a different performer in comedy. He used the same serious timing he brought to drama. The script created the collision between the seriousness and the absurdity.
Story is hardware and software
A movie needs a physical, external problem and an internal, psychological problem. I call them hardware and software.
In Airplane!, the hardware is simple and powerful: Ted Striker has to land the plane. The software is that he has to overcome the trauma that has ruined his confidence and damaged his relationship. He cannot hold a job, he is losing Elaine, and he is emotionally stuck. The external emergency gives him the opportunity to fix the internal problem.
That is why the movie works beyond the jokes. The audience has somebody to root for. Ted is a lovable loser with a giant problem, and he has to change by the third act.
Not every character needs an arc. The central characters do. The doctor does not need an emotional transformation. The air traffic controller does not need one. You do not have to resolve every supporting player’s life, either. We learned that on Ruthless People, where a scene resolving a secondary character’s story was unnecessary and got cut.
Structure is the same for comedy and drama:
- Act One: Get the hero up a tree.
- Act Two: Throw stones at the hero.
- Act Three: Get the hero down.
In Airplane!, Ted gets stones thrown at him constantly. Mechanical failures, turbulence, pressure, conflict, impossible decisions. Every obstacle makes the landing harder and makes the eventual payoff more satisfying.
Attention comes from what happens next
Social media can keep people scrolling, but a feature film has a much harder job. It has to hold attention for 90 minutes or two hours because the story creates momentum. The question on every page should be: What happens next?
That starts in the script. If the script makes someone want to turn the page, that energy can carry into the finished film. You cannot fix a dead script with noise, effects, or technical pizzazz.
And do not confuse expensive with funny. In spoof, something that looks too expensive can become less funny. Comedy benefits from a certain simplicity. If the audience becomes impressed by the production budget, they may stop noticing the joke.
Comedy Mastercrash
Comedy can be taught, at least the craft can. Inspiration is mysterious, but the mechanics are not entirely mysterious once you start breaking down why a gag works, why another gag dies, and why a good story can make jokes hit harder.
Mastercrash began with 15 rules of spoof comedy, with a lesson for each rule. It has grown into a community where writers can bring in work and get direct feedback. That is useful because I am not there merely to say, “Great job.” I can tell someone what is wrong with it.
That process is useful for me, too. Teaching forces you to examine your own instincts. Sometimes a student’s pages reveal something I did wrong in one of my own movies. That is a healthy thing. If you stop learning, you should probably take up stamp collecting. Although I do not know whether stamp collecting has notes.
The point of a comedy course is not to make every writer sound alike. The Wayans have their own rules. Mel Brooks had his own style. Woody Allen had his own style. Seinfeld and Larry David have a skill I would not pretend to possess. You have to recognize the difference between admiring somebody and attempting to become them.
Mel Brooks could make a comedy such as Young Frankenstein with a cast full of comic performers playing comedy. It worked because it was Mel Brooks. Woody Allen could evolve from pure comedies such as Bananas into Annie Hall and Crimes and Misdemeanors. It worked because that evolution was genuine.
There is a lot of advice telling artists to get out of their comfort zone. Sometimes that is right. Sometimes it is nonsense. You can do excellent work inside your lane if it is truly your lane. Stay authentic. Expand when you genuinely have somewhere to go, not because someone thinks discomfort is automatically profound.
There are also times when no new idea arrives. That happens. After Airplane!, there was a period before the next great idea. After The Naked Gun, there was another period. I do not panic. I build a house, work on architecture or interior design, spend time with family, pursue other projects, and keep creating in some form.
Film cannot be the entire center of life because it is too undependable. There will be long periods when no movie is moving ahead, financing is impossible, or a studio does something you cannot control. Have other interests. Have family. Plant trees. Make something. Then when the big idea shows up, you are ready for it.
7 Hidden Rules Of Comedy
The 15 rules of spoof overlap, but seven of them explain a great deal about why jokes survive or die. They are not laws of nature. Rule 15 is that there are no rules. But they are good rules to understand before breaking them.
1. Make yourself laugh
Write what you think is funny. Do not write a joke because you assume some imaginary demographic will like it. If you are not amused, it is very difficult to create something with a real comic voice.
Of course, making yourself laugh does not mean making private inside jokes. The audience must be able to share the reference and understand the basic situation. That is one reason visual comedy travels so well internationally.
2. Do not rely on trivia
A reference is not a joke merely because it is a reference. In spoof, the audience needs to know what is being referenced. Disaster films, hard-boiled cop movies, and horror conventions work because they are broadly familiar.
Very contemporary references are dangerous because they age. Physical comedy is more durable. A visual gag can work with the sound off. A reference to a once-famous singer or current celebrity may become meaningless in a few decades. Some references in Airplane! are already less clear than they were when the film came out, and that is a regret.
3. Use as little setup as possible
Setup is necessary, but too much of it lets the audience predict the payoff. The goal is to give just enough information for the gag to land and no more.
I tend to see a script page visually. A speech should not run beyond about six lines. At seven lines, I am cutting words. Long speeches can be useful in drama, but in a fast spoof they often slow the engine down.
4. Let the audience discover the joke
This is the rule of acknowledgement. Sometimes the characters should react to something odd. Sometimes they should ignore it completely. The choice is technical, but it makes a huge difference.
In Airplane!, while one character suffers grotesque food-poisoning symptoms in the background, the foreground conversation simply continues. Nobody acknowledges it. That makes it funnier.
Other times, a small reaction is exactly right. In The Naked Gun, when an absurdly contradictory medical prognosis is delivered, Leslie Nielsen gives a look. But the reaction stays in the same shot. Do not cut in and underline the joke. Let the audience catch it.
5. Knock down the posts
It is not enough to recreate a familiar dramatic image and expect laughter because people recognize it. A spoof needs to do something comic with the image.
In Airplane!, there is a romantic goodbye sequence modeled on an old wartime train farewell. A woman runs alongside the plane as though it were a train. That reference alone was not enough. It became funny when she started knocking down the posts as she ran.
The reference sets up the expectation. The new comic action knocks it down.
6. Can you live with it?
A gag may be funny for one second but exhausting for an entire scene. Ask whether the movie can live with the consequence.
When Leslie Nielsen’s lips turn pink from pistachios, the joke happens and then disappears. When someone crashes through a skylight and becomes battered, the movie does not have to carry the battered makeup through the next scene. When Val Kilmer emerges from a lake with soaked hair in Top Secret!, he can immediately smooth it back into perfect shape. The gag is over. Move on.
This is not realism. It is comic economy. Once a joke has done its job, do not let it become a burden.
7. Be careful about axe grinding and breaking reality
Axe grinding is using comedy to make a political point rather than to make a joke. It can be done, but it is risky. Half the audience may disagree, miss the point, or simply decide it is not funny. An American Carol was an attempt to make a political comedy loaded with jokes, but it was too controversial to reach a broad audience. Some lessons cost money.
Breaking the fourth wall is similar. It can destroy the believable reality of a story because the audience has to accept that the drama is happening. But if the joke is strong enough, break it.
In Top Secret!, after a character recounts an unbelievable chain of events, another character notes that it sounds like a bad movie. The characters then look outward as if they heard the reaction. It worked because the gag was worth the disruption.
Rules are there to protect the movie, not imprison it. If a joke is good enough, you can get away with almost anything. But it had better be good enough.
The lasting principle is simple: make the movie work as a movie first. Give the lead character a real problem, give the story momentum, cast people who understand the tone, play it seriously, cut ruthlessly, and never confuse a reference with a laugh.
Then, if someone runs beside an airplane knocking down posts, there is at least a chance it will be funny.
Frequently Asked Questions About Spoof Comedy
What makes spoof comedy different from a sketch comedy movie?
Strong spoof comedy uses a real story, believable stakes, and serious performances as the foundation. The jokes are built into the writing, staging, editing, and visual world rather than being performed as isolated sketches.
Why should actors play spoof comedy seriously?
Playing the material straight creates the contrast that makes absurd situations funny. In this style, the actor is usually the straight person while the writer supplies the comedy.
Do comedy movies need character arcs?
Yes, central characters need an internal problem to resolve. A comedy can have wall-to-wall jokes, but without a lead character worth rooting for and a meaningful change by the end, the ending will not feel satisfying.
What are the hardware and software problems in a screenplay?
The hardware problem is the external plot challenge, such as landing a damaged plane. The software problem is the character’s internal psychological conflict, such as overcoming trauma or fear. A strong story uses the external challenge to force internal change.
How can a writer avoid copying another filmmaker’s style?
Learn from artists you admire, but do not imitate their finished work. Transform influences through your own comic voice, new characters, fresh circumstances, and an original premise. If the idea depends on replacing somebody else’s iconic character and repeating old beats, it is probably copying.
