This Week I Learned…
Who cares whether fall has officially started yet? It has started in this house. September is flying by, October is right around the corner, and that means it is time to bring on the spooky reads, spooky movies, cooler weather aspirations, and all the good stuff that comes with the season.
It has been one of those weeks where we have had a lot going on across books, channel discussions, podcast appearances, future horror plans, and a little bit of television news to chew on. The big reading takeaway, though, is that Malazan remains Malazan. Even eight books deep into the Toll the Hounds page on Goodreads, this series can still make us stop, stare at a paragraph, and wonder exactly what kind of philosophical degree Stephen Erikson expects us to earn before the end.
That is not necessarily a complaint. It is just the deal when we sign up for the Malazan Book of the Fallen. There are going to be huge ideas, enormous casts, old friends returning from books we read what feels like a lifetime ago, and moments where the best strategy is simply to keep reading and trust that the pieces will eventually start to fit.
Fall is here in spirit, the reading stack is looking great, and there is plenty to talk about.
What Am I Reading?
We are about a third of the way through Toll the Hounds, book eight in Steven Erikson’s Malazan Book of the Fallen. This is our third attempt at the book, and the good news is that it is already the furthest we have made it.
The other good news is that the first couple hundred pages did not feel overly repetitive, despite having started the novel twice before. Apparently, not much of that earlier reading experience stuck. That probably tells us something about just how deliberately paced this opening section can be.
Calling Toll the Hounds difficult is not exactly breaking news. This is Malazan. Difficulty is baked into the whole experience. Yet it has felt a little more approachable this time around because the book appears more interested in character work than in throwing a giant, wild plot contraption at us immediately.
That can make it slow, but at this point in the series, slow is not necessarily bad. Sometimes we need room to breathe. Sometimes we need to recognize a name, remember where we encountered that person, and piece together what they did several books ago before the story starts sprinting again.
A Malazan Homecoming
The real highlight so far has been returning to Darujhistan and reconnecting with characters we have not spent time with since Gardens of the Moon. There is a strange homecoming quality to it. It feels a little like running into people we went through a war with years ago, except everyone has changed, grown older, carried scars, and become somebody else in the time since.
Seeing the Bridgeburners and other familiar faces again has been genuinely rewarding. Erikson has always been willing to send readers across continents, eras, cultures, military campaigns, and metaphysical realms. Coming back to these earlier characters gives the novel an emotional anchor. We may not always immediately understand every philosophical monologue or every hint being dropped, but we know these people. Or at least we remember enough to be glad they are back.
That familiarity helps. Malazan is demanding when read entirely with the eyes on the page. There is so much happening at once, and there are so many names, locations, histories, and interconnected threads to hold onto. We have a lifeline available if we need one, but so far, we have not had to use it. We are recognizing enough names and connections to keep rolling.
The Good: Character Development Over Chaos
There are things to appreciate about the slower build. The book feels more focused on how people have been altered by their lives than on immediately advancing a giant central plot. That can be refreshing after spending so much time in a series where every new storyline may eventually turn into an apocalyptic collision of armies, gods, ascendants, undead creatures, and things nobody can adequately explain in one sentence.
For now, the intimate material is working better than expected. We are enjoying the reunion aspect and seeing how years of pain, loyalty, regret, and survival have changed the people we first encountered in the early Malazan books.
There is something particularly satisfying about returning to a huge fantasy world and discovering that the characters have not been frozen in place. They have continued to become themselves, even when we have been off spending hundreds or thousands of pages with entirely different factions.
The Not-So-Good: Everybody Has a Philosophy Degree
At the same time, there is no getting around the fact that Toll the Hounds is very, very slow in places. Even when we are not confused, we can still be a little bored. A lot of people are sitting around, reflecting on pain, morality, war, humanity, and the terrible condition of the world. It can feel like everybody in the cast suddenly has a PhD in philosophy.
Malazan characters have always been capable of waxing poetic. That is part of the flavor. But here, it feels as if nearly everyone is deeply introspective all the time. There is plenty of naval gazing. There is plenty of reflection. There are moments where it feels as though the entire cast read God Emperor of Dune and then decided to give their best impression of it.
Again, that is not all bad. A series this interested in trauma, grief, war, compassion, history, and human suffering should have something to say. Erikson was dealing with the loss of his father while writing the book, and that sense of pain and emotional scarring seems to be present in the material, even if the direct focus on grief has not fully emerged yet.
Still, goodness, it is a lot.
And then there is Kruppe. We know this is a divisive opinion, but Kruppe has never been a character we have particularly loved. Having him serve as such a prominent narrative presence is not exactly the welcome-back party we wanted. Plenty of Malazan fans adore the character, and that is perfectly fine. We are just over here hoping the book eventually shifts its focus enough that we can get more momentum.
Waiting for the Back Half
We have heard from plenty of readers that the back half of Toll the Hounds is excellent. That is encouraging because the main challenge right now is simply getting there. Nothing has gone truly off the rails. There has not been a major bad reading hiccup. It is more that familiar Malazan feeling where we reach a point and think, “Yep, we need to read something else for a minute.”
That is why we rarely binge Malazan novels without a break. They are rich, dense, complicated books that ask for a lot of concentration. Some readers can power through them on audio, and honestly, that is a superpower. We do not have it. There is too much happening, too much texture in the prose, and too many details that seem likely to matter later.
For now, Toll the Hounds is going fine. It is not quite lighting the world on fire yet, but it is also not the disaster a third attempt might suggest. We are enjoying the returning characters, appreciating the breathing room, and waiting for that promised momentum to arrive.
What Am I Going to Read?
Toll the Hounds is likely going to take us through the rest of the month. We are not trying to force it. This is a book that needs time, attention, and the occasional palate cleanser.
That counterbalance has officially begun with Coffin Moon by Keith Rosson. Spooky season has started early around here, and this is exactly the kind of book that seems suited to the moment. The edition from Black Crow Books is beautiful, as usual. They consistently put out striking work, and this one looks fantastic on the shelf before we even get into what is between the covers.
We are only a few chapters in, but the setting is already doing a lot of heavy lifting. The story takes place in the 1970s, and that is a big part of the appeal. There is something about horror set before the modern smartphone era that just lands differently.
Why Pre-Modern Horror Still Works
Modern horror has its own challenges. Once everybody has a phone with a camera, a flashlight, GPS, instant communication, and access to the entire internet in their pocket, some traditional horror setups become harder to sell. That does not mean contemporary horror cannot work, but it does mean the story has to account for all that technology.
Period horror gets to sidestep some of those issues. If something terrible happens in a remote location, nobody is pulling out a phone to record it, search it, call for help, or post it online. The isolation becomes more believable. The uncertainty feels more immediate.
The Conjuring films understood that. Setting supernatural horror in an earlier era allows the atmosphere to breathe without having to spend half the runtime explaining why no one is simply using an app to solve the problem. In a 1970s setting, the world is still recognizable, but it is just far enough removed from modern convenience that danger can feel more inescapable.
Vietnam, Vampires, and Revenge
Coffin Moon has a protagonist who is a Vietnam veteran, which immediately gives the story some emotional weight. This is a character who has already been through terrible things. He has seen things most people should never have to see, and now the sense is that the nightmare is only beginning.
There are hints of suspicious characters entering a bar and giving off some extremely bad vibes. The vampires have not fully revealed themselves yet, but the setup has promise. A 1970s vampire tale with a damaged veteran and what appears to be a revenge-driven premise sounds like a pretty good time.
Sometimes all we need is a clean hook:
- A strong period setting
- A lead character carrying real baggage
- Some possible revenge on the horizon
- Vampires
That is enough to get us interested. We will have more to say once we have spent more time with it, but Coffin Moon already feels like a fun way to break up the philosophical endurance test that is Toll the Hounds.
This Week on the Channel
This week brought a return to Stephen King’s multiverse, a discussion about whether fantasy needs more heroes again, and a really fun conversation with Blake Crouch about the second season of Dark Matter.
Revisiting Lisey’s Story
We went back into the Stephen King multiverse with Lisey’s Story, a novel that tends to produce a strong reaction one way or another. It is not necessarily divisive in the traditional sense. It is more a matter of whether it clicks for someone. For many readers, it does. For others, it absolutely does not.
This is a very different Stephen King book. At that point in his career, there had been a run of novels where it sometimes felt like he was revisiting things he had already done better earlier in his career. The thought can creep in: are we entering a phase where the work feels less essential?
Then Lisey’s Story arrives, and it is deeply personal. It does not feel like King going through familiar motions. It feels like a book he needed to write.
The challenge is that it asks for trust. The first section is slow and intentionally confusing. Lisey and her late husband Scott shared a private language, the kind of strange vocabulary and inside phrases that long-term couples build together after decades. The book drops readers into that language before offering much explanation.
At first, it can feel like everybody is speaking English, but not really. The experience is a little like beginning Dune and encountering a pile of unfamiliar terms before the world begins to take shape. That is the only comparison we need to make between Lisey’s Story and Dune, but the initial reaction can be similar.
Once the flashback material starts gaining traction, the novel becomes much stronger. The world of Boo’ya Moon is compelling, strange, and full of the kind of multiverse implications that make Stephen King fans start asking questions. Is this connected to The Talisman? Is it brushing up against The Dark Tower? What other worlds might be out there?
The answers are part of the fun. But this is also a book about love, memory, marriage, creativity, trauma, and loss. If someone has recently lost a loved one, it might be worth saving Lisey’s Story for later. It is not quite as relentlessly miserable as Pet Sematary, but it can absolutely hit hard.
Are Modern Fantasy Readers Ready for Heroes Again?
Another big topic this week was heroic fantasy. We have found ourselves saying repeatedly that heroic fantasy still works, and eventually that led to a bigger question: at what point did heroes stop being cool?
For us, they never did.
There was a stretch where audiences became understandably tired of clean-cut heroism. People wanted deconstruction. They wanted flawed people, moral ambiguity, compromised ideals, and stories willing to examine the darker side of power. Works like Watchmen showed how powerful that approach could be when it was fresh and well executed.
Fantasy followed a similar path. Series such as George R. R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire and Joe Abercrombie’s The First Law did grimdark exceptionally well. We love those books. The problem is not grimdark itself. The problem is what happens when every other series starts trying to copy the same playbook.
Eventually, the subversion becomes the trope.
When every hero is secretly awful, every kingdom is irredeemably corrupt, every noble purpose is a lie, and every major character is waiting to reveal that they eat babies in chapter 48, genuine goodness becomes the surprising thing. A character who simply wants to protect people, keep a promise, or do the right thing can suddenly feel radical.
That does not mean fantasy should go backward. Nobody is asking for the genre to abandon complexity, danger, trauma, political tension, or moral ambiguity. We are simply ready for stories that remember heroism is not automatically corny. A good person can be interesting. A hero can be flawed without being rotten to the core. A fantasy world can be dark without insisting that everyone in it is beyond saving.
There is room for all of it:
- Grimdark that explores a brutal world without turning into imitation.
- Heroic fantasy where courage and decency matter.
- Epic fantasy with vast worlds and enormous stakes.
- Character-driven fantasy that finds meaning in smaller choices.
The genre is at its best when it is not chasing one trend until that trend has exhausted itself.
Talking Dark Matter With Blake Crouch
One of the coolest things to happen this week was joining the official Dark Matter podcast for a conversation with Blake Crouch. As a longtime fan of the book, it was a real pleasure to get to discuss the story and its continuing life on Apple TV+.
The first season adapted the full novel, but season two will continue the story in a different medium. That distinction matters. This is not a case of a studio simply deciding to extend a finished story without the original creator’s involvement. Blake Crouch is writing the continuation and remains deeply involved with the series.
That is why this feels different from the usual concern about limited stories being stretched into endless television. The question asked was simple: what made him think there was more story to tell after an ending that already worked?
The answer came down to the possibilities that emerged while making the first season. As the story approached its conclusion, new jumping-off points became clear, especially surrounding where the Dessen family might end up after entering the corridor one last time. There was an opportunity to make a sequel, just not in the form of another novel.
That is an exciting prospect for fans of the original book. Dark Matter remains one of those stories that balances big science fiction concepts with a deeply emotional core. If the author who created it is continuing the journey, we are absolutely willing to see where it goes.
The full conversation runs about an hour and can be found through Apple Podcasts and the official Dark Matter channels.
Next Week Plans
Spooky season plans are coming together. The October reading list has been finalized, with some helpful feedback from Patreon supporters along the way. That does not mean anyone else gets to dictate the entire reading schedule, but good feedback is good feedback, and it helped make the final lineup more balanced.
The goal is variety. Horror has too many great subgenres to spend an entire month reading the same type of book over and over. The October picks include a mix of:
- Coming-of-age horror
- Survival horror
- Psychological horror
- Demonic possession horror
That should keep things fresh. One of the coming-of-age horror selections is already known, and we are very excited to return to that territory. The remaining October choices will be announced soon.
There is also a monthly AMA planned after dropping the car off for warranty work. The heating and cooling seats decided to stop cooperating, so that needs to be handled. But afterward, it should be time to settle in for another live question-and-answer session.
These monthly AMAs have been a great time. As long as people keep showing up and bringing questions, we will keep doing them. It is fun to have a direct conversation about books, movies, television, reading habits, and whatever else comes up without relying on the hope that we might find and answer a random comment days or weeks later.
TV & Movie Talk
NFL season has been taking up a lot of free time, so television and movie consumption has slowed down a bit. Still, there are a couple of major topics worth discussing, beginning with Mike Flanagan and The Dark Tower.
Mike Flanagan’s The Dark Tower Is Still Alive
Mike Flanagan has recently made encouraging comments about his planned adaptation of Stephen King’s The Dark Tower. There was a long stretch of silence after the initial announcement, enough that it was fair to wonder whether the project had stalled or whether rights complications had gotten in the way.
According to Flanagan, though, it is still very much alive. He is continuing to work on it. The biggest hurdle appears to be getting a studio commitment for the scope of the project he wants to make.
That is probably about more than money, although a faithful Dark Tower adaptation would not be cheap. This is a massive story. There are enormous landscapes, strange worlds, complicated mythology, major action sequences, monsters, supernatural elements, and genre shifts that take the story from Western to fantasy to horror to science fiction and beyond.
But the real issue may be a commitment to tell the full story. A project like this cannot be made halfway. It is understandable that Flanagan would want a clear plan for enough episodes and enough seasons to reach the end rather than launching a huge undertaking only to have it disappear before the ka-tet completes the journey.
There are also the crossover complications. The Dark Tower multiverse brushes against characters and stories whose rights may be held by different studios. Salem’s Lot is an obvious example of the kind of property that could complicate matters.
Still, if Sony and Disney can find a way to work out a deal involving Spider-Man, surely there has to be a path for studios to cooperate when the right story and the right people are involved. It may involve money, but it probably involves egos too. Hollywood is never quite that simple.
We remain hopeful because few filmmakers working today seem to understand Stephen King as well as Mike Flanagan. Frank Darabont has done extraordinary King adaptations. Rob Reiner has done extraordinary King adaptations. But Flanagan has repeatedly demonstrated that he understands the emotional heart beneath King’s monsters, weirdness, and mythology.
He seems like the kind of creator who would rather not make The Dark Tower at all than make a bad version of it. That is exactly the mindset we want holding Roland, Eddie, Susannah, Jake, Oy, and the whole ka-tet in its hands.
This Year’s Horror Movie Plans
Every year, we try to put together a spooky-season movie list. Last year, we made a big announcement, chose our titles, and then completely dropped the ball. A vacation, outside obligations, and life in general got in the way, and we only ended up getting through around six movies.
That is not how we like to do it, so this year we are keeping expectations realistic. We have still made a list. We have still watched trailers. We have still narrowed down a group of films that we want to get to. But we are not making grand promises about completing an enormous marathon.
School is part of the reason. There is less free time in the evenings now, and that is just reality. The idea is to enjoy the movies we do get to rather than turn the season into another obligation.
The top selections are set:
- Malignant was the first pick. It is a James Wan film that somehow slipped through the cracks despite a love for his work on movies like The Conjuring and Insidious.
- The Devil Made Me Do It was the other top choice. It was on last year’s list but did not happen, and the old-school late-night talk-show aesthetic looks like a lot of fun.
The Devil Made Me Do It looks especially appealing because it seems to capture that strange, low-budget 1970s television energy. Anybody who grew up finding weird shows on rabbit-ear television late at night knows the vibe: cheap sets, bizarre guests, unsettling claims, and the feeling that something is about to get genuinely strange.
The home theater space is still a work in progress, too. The screen is up, which is a good start, but the room itself is currently being reconstructed. Furniture is gone, music and movie collections are all over the place, and it is nowhere near ready for recording. Hopefully it will come together in time for some holiday-season content, but for now, the important thing is that the screen is there.
That is a win.
FAQ
What book is currently being read in the Malazan series?
We are reading Toll the Hounds, the eighth book in Steven Erikson’s Malazan Book of the Fallen.
Why is Toll the Hounds taking longer than expected?
The novel is dense, slow-paced, highly philosophical, and filled with returning characters and long-running story threads. It benefits from being balanced with lighter or faster reads.
What spooky-season book has started?
Coffin Moon by Keith Rosson has started. It is a 1970s-set horror story featuring a Vietnam veteran, ominous strangers, and vampires.
Is Mike Flanagan still developing The Dark Tower?
Yes. Mike Flanagan has indicated that the project remains active, though securing a studio commitment for the scope and length of the adaptation is a major challenge.
Why does a second season of Dark Matter feel different from other television continuations?
The continuation is being written by Blake Crouch, the author of the original novel, and expands the story in television form rather than simply extending it without the creator’s involvement.
