This Week I Learned…
We have learned something about ourselves that, honestly, probably should not have taken this long to figure out. No matter how huge the gaming backlog gets, no matter how many games are sitting there patiently waiting for us to finish them, we are apparently never going to stop buying new video games.
It is a sickness. It is also the life we have chosen.
September is here, fall is finally beginning to show its face, and that means we are entering the time of year when all of our favorite things start piling up at once. There are books to read, big fantasy series to return to, horror movies to try, games to buy, and probably far too little time to give all of them the attention they deserve.
Still, that is a good problem to have. This week included a completed David Gemmell novel, a new dystopian read on deck, thoughts about the future of fantasy standalones, a very cool Japanese psychological horror movie, and yet another game purchase that has been added to the ever-growing mountain. So, business as usual around here.
What Am I Reading?
We finished The King Beyond the Gate by David Gemmell, the second novel in the Drenai Saga. It was also Philip Chase’s latest selection for the Book Club, so there will be a much more thorough discussion of it with spoiler-free and spoiler sections over on Philip Chase’s channel.
For now, the short version is pretty simple. Heroic fantasy still works for us.
It is not trying to reinvent the wheel. Gemmell is not coming at this with some labyrinthine magic system or a hundred pages of fictional history before anything happens. This is old-school, character-focused heroic fantasy with battles, loyalty, sacrifice, redemption, hard choices, and people trying to stand for something when the world around them would rather they did not.
If that kind of fantasy is not usually your thing, this probably is not going to be the book that changes your mind. But for those of us who came to the genre because we love those classic building blocks, there is a whole lot to enjoy here.
Connavar Is a Stronger Lead Than We Expected
The biggest difference between this novel and Legend is that we were much more invested in the protagonist this time around. Connavar is a compelling lead because he is a man caught between identities. He is a mixed-blood outsider, distrusted by both sides of his heritage, and forced to decide where his loyalties really lie.
That kind of setup is catnip for us. A protagonist without an obvious home, trying to earn trust while being pulled in different directions, has immediate emotional stakes. Connavar has to make sacrifices. He has to confront the expectations that others place on him. He has to figure out what kind of man he wants to become when no one is offering him an easy answer.
Those elements give the story weight beyond the action. It is still very much a fast-moving adventure, but there is a real through line involving identity, leadership, and whether someone can ever escape the assumptions people make about them.
That was especially welcome after our experience with Legend. In that book, Druss absolutely stole the show. We loved him. We wanted more of him. When he was on the page, the novel had this extra level of charisma that was hard to resist. The main protagonist in Legend, however, never connected with us in the same way. We do not have to like every protagonist in every story, but it is hard to deny that it helps when we are not quietly rooting against them.
With Connavar, that problem is gone. He is a character we could follow. He has flaws, he has burdens, and he makes mistakes, but he is someone we were firmly in the corner of from early on.
A Ragtag Band and Some Surprisingly Big Ideas
The supporting cast is good as well. Nobody quite reaches the impossible standard set by Druss, but Gemmell puts together a group of characters who are enjoyable to spend time with. There is always something satisfying about a ragtag collection of people being thrown into a dangerous situation and gradually becoming a unit.
More than anything, though, The King Beyond the Gate has some ideas beneath the swordplay that landed for us. The book is interested in hero worship, in the temptation to wait for someone else to save the day, and in the danger of putting too much faith in a single powerful figure.
That can create tyrants just as easily as it can create heroes.
There were moments where the themes felt a little Frank Herbert-esque, particularly in the way the story considers the burden and risk of elevating a person into a symbol. It is not remotely as dense as Dune, nor is it attempting to be. But it shares some of that skepticism around messianic figures and the way people can surrender their own agency while waiting for a great person to lead them.
That is a theme we can always get behind. Heroism is complicated. People can do great things and still become something dangerous when the world stops questioning them.
The Gemmell Formula Is Still a Formula We Like
One of the great strengths here is just how readable this novel is. It moves. The prose is lean, direct, and not interested in wasting time. The action comes quickly, scenes turn over fast, and before long we had burned through the book in only a few sittings.
That is not always an easy trick to pull off. A short, fast book can still feel rushed or undercooked. Gemmell mostly avoids that problem because he knows how to keep the story pointed forward. There is always another conflict approaching, another decision to make, another fight waiting around the corner.
For a Book Club pick, this kind of read is honestly a nice change of pace. We say all the time that we want to get outside our comfort zones, and while heroic fantasy itself is hardly unfamiliar territory around here, it is refreshing to pick up a book that is not asking for a three-month commitment and a spreadsheet.
Sometimes we want a giant ten-book fantasy saga with maps, appendices, ancient gods, and 900-page installments. Sometimes we just want a guy with a sword, a troubled past, and a problem that must be solved before everyone dies.
There is room for both.
Where The King Beyond the Gate Falls Short
Of course, no book is perfect, and this one has some very clear weaknesses.
The first is that, for much of its opening half, it feels a little too much like an echo of Legend. We would not call it a total retread, because the book eventually finds more of its own identity. But there were definitely stretches where it felt like Gemmell was saying, “Remember that book you liked? Here is something that should feel familiar.”
It may simply be the Gemmell formula. Authors have patterns, especially authors who write in a genre built around archetypes and recurring themes. We do not necessarily mind a formula when it works. But the resemblance to Legend was hard to ignore at times, especially in the first half.
Then there is the Druss problem.
Again, the supporting characters in this book are good. But Druss is Druss. He has the kind of immediate presence that makes us want to keep reading just to see what he does next. He is the measuring stick now, and that is not exactly fair to anyone else. Yet it is difficult not to notice his absence.
We are only two David Gemmell books in, but it is easy to understand why Druss has become such a legendary character among fantasy readers. We barely knew him, and we still wanted an entire shelf of novels about him. That says something.
The pace can also work against the book occasionally. We loved that it never dragged, but the story sometimes needs to slow down and breathe. There is a point where fast-paced action can become a substitute for actual development. Punching and stabbing are fun. We enjoy punching and stabbing in fantasy as much as anybody. But we also want opportunities to understand the characters when they are not swinging a sword.
That is something a writer like Tad Williams does exceptionally well. In The Heart of What Was Lost, there are stretches that move with tremendous speed, but Williams still makes room for character moments, reflection, and emotional texture. A story does not have to choose between exciting plot momentum and depth. The strongest fantasy finds ways to give us both.
Finally, the romance was not for us. Not at all.
We absolutely believe in love at first sight. We are not anti-romance. Quite the opposite. Give us a genuinely well-developed love story and we are all in. But the romantic relationships here happen at warp speed. It is not merely attraction. It is almost instant devotion, with characters behaving as if they have known one another forever after what feels like a few conversations.
That is a tough sell in such a short novel. If the series were more connected, perhaps those relationships could have unfolded over multiple books. But these stories tend to be fairly standalone in nature, so there is not necessarily much space to allow that development to happen.
Still, despite all of those criticisms, we had a good time with The King Beyond the Gate. We might even say we liked it a little more than Legend overall, although it never reaches the highs that Legend hits whenever Druss is front and center.
Gemmell may be formulaic. But guess what? We like the formula.
What Am I Going to Read?
Before heading back into the absolute hellscape that is Malazan, we are taking a brief detour into something lighter. The next book up is The Knife of Never Letting Go by Patrick Ness, the first book in the completed Chaos Walking trilogy.
This is one of those books that has been hovering around the TBR for a long time. The strange typography and odd visual presentation inside the book caught our attention during a recent TBR discussion, and sometimes that is all it takes. We see something different and immediately start wondering what the deal is.
The concept is very appealing too. In this world, people cannot keep their thoughts private. Their thoughts are audible. Secrets, as a basic human idea, become nearly impossible.
That premise has a little bit of The Giver energy mixed with a dystopian survival feeling that brings something like The Last of Us to mind. It sounds like a young adult novel, sure, but it also sounds like one with a distinct enough hook to rise above whatever assumptions people might have about YA fiction.
We have heard from plenty of people who do not typically read young adult books that this series works for them anyway. Patrick Ness also comes up often in conversations about Neal Shusterman, with readers saying that Shusterman is good but Ness may handle similar material even better.
We shall find out.
There is also an animal companion involved, and that is an easy win around here. The protagonist has a dog, and the central question we immediately have is obvious: if everyone can hear thoughts, can they hear the dog’s thoughts too?
That matters. Animal companions are already great. An animal companion with an actual voice or meaningful interior perspective is basically a cheat code. Think about Nighteyes in Robin Hobb’s Realm of the Elderlings. That kind of relationship can elevate a story in a hurry.
We will start with book one this week, then prepare ourselves for the return to Malazan. For those who have waited patiently while we took what was supposed to be a short Malazan break that somehow became a very long one, the time is nearly here.
This Week on the Channel
August is officially wrapped up, which means it was time to choose the Book of the Month. It was close. Very close.
In the end, Rogue Squadron took it. There was a small technicality involved, in that it edged out a novella in a very tight race, but sometimes those are the little distinctions that break a tie.
More importantly, it reminded us why we love Star Wars.
We are talking about the old Expanded Universe material, now branded as Star Wars Legends. Call it Legends if you want. We still call it canon in our hearts. Those stories represented a version of the galaxy far, far away that felt carefully handled and deeply respectful of what George Lucas created.
The X-Wing books were completely new territory for us. We had never read them before, and Rogue Squadron was a very satisfying first step into that corner of the universe. It hits the notes that make Star Wars work: camaraderie, aerial action, familiar stakes, and the sense that regular people can make a real difference against enormous odds.
It was a fun reminder that the Star Wars galaxy has room for more than Jedi, Sith, and the same handful of characters. Sometimes you just want to get into a cockpit with a squadron of pilots and get to work.
Are Fantasy Standalones Dead?
Another topic this week was whether the fantasy standalone is dying out.
To be clear, this is not an argument that series are bad. Some of our favorite stories of all time are long series. We love a trilogy. We love an epic. We are about to jump back into Malazan, which should tell you everything you need to know about our willingness to commit to a giant fictional undertaking.
But it is fair to ask what happened to the fantasy standalone.
They still exist, technically. The problem is that many “standalones” are now 900-page monsters. Or they are standalones that take place in a shared universe, which means they are often less standalone than advertised. Or they become successful and the author eventually returns to the setting because, well, publishing is publishing.
There is nothing inherently wrong with any of that. A single massive novel can be excellent. A shared setting can be rewarding. A sequel can be welcome. But there is something special about picking up one book, meeting a cast of characters, experiencing a complete world and story, then saying goodbye at the end.
It feels increasingly rare.
The growing trend of debut authors arriving with “Book One of Nine” attached to their first release is particularly interesting. That is a serious ask. Maybe the story needs nine books. Maybe it does not. But when each of those books is 700 or 800 pages, readers are being asked to make a commitment of thousands upon thousands of pages before knowing whether the story will even stay strong.
There is room for both approaches. We need big series because some worlds and characters need space to breathe. We need more than action scenes to understand people and build an attachment to them. But we also need the occasional concise, self-contained fantasy story that has the courage to tell us one great tale and then get out.
Not every book needs an overdeveloped magic system, twelve planned installments, and a lore bible large enough to qualify as a weapon. Sometimes a strong world, memorable characters, and a satisfying ending are enough.
Next Week Plans
There are a couple things on deck for the coming week, starting with a long overdue appreciation post for the pile of books that has been sent in by publishers, authors, and generous members of the community.
It is always overwhelming to look at that stack. There is no way we will realistically get to every single book, and we want to be honest about that. The number of books that exist, combined with the number being released every year, means that no reader can possibly cover it all.
But the thought absolutely counts.
Every package, every recommendation, every book sent with the hope that it may find the right reader someday, that all means something. We are continually blown away by that generosity. And we never say never. Books can sit on a shelf for years and still find their moment. Sometimes the timing is simply not right until it is.
The other big plan is Malazan related.
We are returning to Steven Erikson’s Malazan Book of the Fallen, beginning with Toll the Hounds. Yes, we are picking up where we left off. No, we are not starting from the beginning.
That may sound completely insane to some people. There are readers who stop around book six, forget everything, and decide the only reasonable option is to begin all over again. We respect the commitment. We do not have it in us.
We did not know what was going on the first time through Malazan anyway. That is part of the experience. There is no point pretending we will suddenly emerge with a perfect memory and total mastery of the lore if we restart. We are going into Toll the Hounds, and we are going to figure it out as we go.
Hell or high water.
There will be something Malazan related coming up soon, even if it is mostly us admitting that returning to this series after a long break is a little terrifying. But it is time. The break was never intended to last this long. We always said we would come back when the mood struck, and apparently the mood has finally struck.
TV & Movie Talk
We took a chance on a Japanese psychological horror movie called Exit 8, and it turned out to be a really cool little experience.
We are big fans of Korean and Japanese horror. They are not all winners, obviously, but they often feel more willing to take chances than mainstream American horror. There is a willingness to be strange, uncomfortable, patient, and sometimes downright ruthless that can make the best entries in those genres incredibly memorable.
Exit 8 is not the kind of horror movie that is going to leave anyone unable to sleep because of monsters jumping out of closets. The horror is fairly restrained. But if its central situation happened in real life, it would absolutely be terrifying.
The closest comparison is something like The Backrooms crossed with Alice in Borderland. A man finds himself trapped in a looping section of a subway corridor. He has to move through the same space repeatedly, identify abnormalities, and make the correct decisions in order to advance.
Get one right, and the counter rises. Get one wrong, and the counter resets to zero.
He needs to reach level eight to escape.
That is a deeply simple concept, but it is executed in a way that makes the repetition part of the tension. We start memorizing the hallway alongside the protagonist. Where is the door? Does that sign look different? Was that poster always there? Is something wrong with the vent? Why is that doorknob in the wrong place?
It becomes an oddly interactive experience because every little detail begins to matter. This is probably not the ideal movie for anyone who demands complete silence during a film, because it is hard not to call out the discrepancies as they appear.
The atmosphere is excellent. That sense of helplessness, of being trapped somewhere that should be familiar but is constantly just a little wrong, is captured extremely well. The real horror is not blood or gore. It is the mounting frustration of being unable to escape, the fear of making the wrong choice, and the psychological pressure of having progress erased over and over again.
The ending is ambiguous, but it is ambiguous in the right way. It does not feel like a cheap refusal to provide answers. It leaves room for interpretation. We came away with different readings of what happened. One of us leaned optimistic, while the other had a much more pessimistic view that the protagonist may be trapped in that nightmare loop forever.
There also seems to be a possible theme about accepting responsibility. The protagonist is anxious about becoming a father, and the entire ordeal can be read as a kind of confrontation with uncertainty. Nobody knows exactly how parenthood is going to go. Nobody begins as an expert. We are all rookies, learning as we go and hoping we do not screw it up too badly.
Maybe that is reading too much into it. Maybe not. Either way, Exit 8 is recommended, especially for anyone who likes psychological horror, liminal spaces, or stories that use a simple premise to create a strong sense of dread. There is very little dialogue, so it is especially accessible for those who usually hesitate around subtitled films. This one is driven by atmosphere more than exposition.
Gaming Talk
Now we arrive at the game we bought despite having dozens and dozens and dozens of games already sitting in the backlog.
The game is The Blood of Dawnwalker, and it seemed to come out of nowhere. We had been talking about how we were somehow more excited about the upcoming Witcher 3 DLC, Songs of the Past, than we were about The Witcher 4. That is not meant as a knock against a new Witcher game. It is simply a reflection of how much we love The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt.
It is one of our favorite games of all time. We have played it more than once, spent an embarrassing amount of time in that world, and still consider it one of the best open-world RPG experiences ever made.
Someone mentioned The Blood of Dawnwalker as something Witcher fans should be keeping an eye on. Then suddenly it was everywhere. The more gameplay footage we saw, the more obvious the connection became. The game is being made by people who worked on The Witcher 3, including its director, and it has that familiar kind of dark fantasy RPG appeal.
That is not a bad thing. We will happily take something that looks and feels like a spiritual cousin to The Witcher 3. People used to call Silent Hill a Resident Evil knockoff, but it was a really good one that became its own landmark horror franchise. If The Blood of Dawnwalker scratches a similar itch while establishing its own identity, we are all for it.
Why It Is Right in Our Wheelhouse
We are still very much solo RPG people. Give us a story-driven open world, a single-player campaign, choices to make, places to explore, and a character to build, and we are happy. Online gaming has never been the thing for us. Couch co-op with the wife? Absolutely. A big solo adventure? Even better.
On paper, The Blood of Dawnwalker has everything we like:
- Dark fantasy atmosphere
- A single-player RPG structure
- An open world to explore
- Developers with major Witcher 3 experience
- A setting and visual style that look distinctively grim and moody
- The potential to fill the gap before more Witcher content arrives
That is a pretty strong sales pitch.
The Combat Is the Big Concern
There is one concern, though, and it is combat.
The footage we have seen makes the fighting look potentially frustrating. To be fair, much of what has been shown appears to come from the opening hours, when the character may be underpowered and players may not fully understand the systems yet. Early-game combat often looks clunkier than it eventually becomes.
Still, seeing a fight against a wolf drag on and on does not exactly inspire confidence.
Our concern is that it may lean too hard into the post-Dark Souls approach to action combat, where every fight is dodge, parry, dodge, parry, dodge, parry forever. We know people love Elden Ring, Dark Souls, Bloodborne, and all of that. More power to them. That style is just not always for us.
We do not want to spend a hundred-hour game locked into an endless series of precisely timed blocks and evasions. Honestly, given that choice, we might rather play a turn-based game.
Combat does not need to be simple or arcade-like. We want strategy. We want decisions. We want challenge. But we also want it to feel fun and varied.
That is what The Witcher 3 did so well. There was dodging and parrying, sure, but there were also signs, potions, oils, sword skills, builds, and different ways to approach fights. It had rhythm without making every encounter feel like a patience test.
The combat concerns are similar to what kept us away from Kingdom Come: Deliverance for so long. The idea of having to block and parry constantly is not exactly a thrilling pitch. We will see how it feels once we actually get some time with The Blood of Dawnwalker. Hopefully, the system opens up after the early hours and becomes more intuitive once the character develops.
Either way, the purchase has been made. The backlog has grown. The reading continues. Malazan is waiting. And somehow we are still looking forward to trying another huge RPG.
That is just who we are now.
FAQ
What book did we finish this week?
We finished The King Beyond the Gate by David Gemmell, the second novel in the Drenai Saga.
Is The King Beyond the Gate worth reading for fans of heroic fantasy?
Yes. It is a fast, highly readable heroic fantasy novel with a strong protagonist, enjoyable supporting characters, memorable action, and themes involving leadership, sacrifice, and hero worship.
What is the next book on the reading list?
The next read is The Knife of Never Letting Go by Patrick Ness, the first book in the Chaos Walking trilogy.
Which Malazan book are we returning to?
We are returning to Steven Erikson’s Malazan Book of the Fallen with Toll the Hounds, without restarting the series from the beginning.
What movie is recommended this week?
Exit 8, a Japanese psychological horror film about a man trapped in a looping subway corridor where he must identify abnormalities to escape.
What game is currently on the radar?
The Blood of Dawnwalker is the current gaming pickup, largely because of its dark fantasy RPG appeal and its connection to developers who worked on The Witcher 3.
